From: Understanding gender norms, nutrition, and physical activity in adolescent girls: a scoping review
Authors year; Country | Objective/Aim | Population | Design, Methodology | Key points |
---|---|---|---|---|
Azzarito L, Solmon MA, Harrison L. 2006; UK | To explore gender roles in PA with postructuralism, investigating how girls negotiate gender relations in PE classes. | High school PE class: teacher and 15 girls, diverse population | Discourse analysis and feminist poststructuralism; Interviews with teacher and girls, field notes, observation. | Evidence supporting complexity of gender barriers; Girls need support in negotiating stereotypes. |
Barr-Anderson DJ, Neumark-Sztainer D, Schmitz KH, et al. 2008; USA | To use a socioecological framework in examining factors influencing PE enjoyment. | 6th grade girls (n = 1511), diverse population | Part of the Trial of Activity for Adolescent Girls (TAAG) to promote girls’ PA; Survey (self-efficacy, perceived benefits of PA), BMI, PA. | PE enjoyment high; Found inverse relationship between BMI and PE enjoyment; Teacher influence associated with PE enjoyment. |
Brooks F, Magnusson J2007; UK | To explore how active adolescent women experience leisure PA, and their perceptions of the relationship between PA and health. | Adolescents aged 14–16 (n = 42), including 6 males | Part of larger study of youth PA in UK health centers; 7 focus groups (2 all girl, 5 mixed gender). | Girls expressed enjoyment of leisure PA but disliked competitiveness of sports; Found PA can be empowering experience, perceived positively for health and wellbeing. |
Clark MI, Spence JC, Holt NL 2011; Canada | To understand how adolescent girls experience PA in their daily lives. | Girls in 6th grade (n = 8), from 1 school in Western Canada | Interpretive description. Two interviews; pre-interview activities including creating collages or drawings. | Found girls have complex relationships with PA. Recommended interventions consider creating spaces where girls feel empowered to negotiate experiences. |
Cockburn C, Clarke G 2002; UK | To explore the aspects of young girls' lives that influence involvement in sport and PE and identity formation. | Girls in 9th grade (n = 6); unspecified ethnicity | Reflexive interpretation and biographical analysis; in-depth semi-structured interviews. | Girls PA can be interpreted as resistance to dominant forces. Found girls felt need to compensate for deviation, creating ‘femininity deficit'. |
Coller TG, Neumark-Sztainer D. 1999; USA | To develop, implement, and evaluate an after-school program to prevent weight occupation and dieting. | Girls ages 10–12 (n = 22); unspecified ethnicity | Intervention in Girl Scout program to address attitudes toward eating, PA, body image, and weight control; Surveys. | Found minimal change in attitudes and behaviors; Concluded intervention needed better focus and that future programs should explore influence of media. |
Derenne JL, Beresin EV2006; USA | To explore and explain the historical context of eating disorders in relation to body image and the media. | N/A: Commentary | Commentary | Explained female ideals change over time but have been unrealistic, associated with fertility, femininity; Current media sends mixed messages about what is attractive; impacts health. |
DeRose LF, Das M, Millman SR 2000; USA | To conduct a review exploring how gender bias affects food distribution. | N/A: Literature review | Literature Review | Indicates women are not at a disadvantage in food allocation; Suggest results difficult to interpret. |
Dunkley TL, Wertheim EH, Paxton SJ 2001; Australia | To test relationships and mechanisms of sociocultural variables in exploring role of media, parents, peers on body image and dietary restraint. | Girls in 10th grade (n = 577) from 6 schools. | Surveys/ scales (pressures from parents, peers, media, body image, and dietary restriction). | Only 15% said they never watched their weight, 30% said they always did. Combined influence of media, parents, and peers was greatest on body dissatisfaction and dietary restraint. Best predictor of body dissatisfaction was larger body size. |
Eisenberg ME, Neumark-Sztainer D, Story M, Perry C 2005; USA | To examine relationship between two social factors (girls trying to lose weight and perceptions of friends dieting), and unhealthy weight control behaviors. | Junior and senior high school girls from 29 schools (n = 2337), from ethnically diverse community. | Part of Project EAT (Eating Among Teens); Survey (dieting norms), BMI. | Found social norms from peer group and at school level may influence UWCBs, particularly for average weight girls. |
Evans B 2006; UK | To compare experiences of girls-only PE to mixed gender PE, using theory of corporeal femininities and inhibited intentionality. | Female adolescents aged 13–16, 90% white. | Draws on data from qualitative and quantitative research with adolescents in UK. | Noted pressure to be both feminine and good at sport; Suggest providing choice and promoting enjoyment, as well as education about resisting pressure to conform to ideals. |
Ferrar KE, Olds TS, Walters JL 2011; Australia | To explore gender-specific time use patterns in adolescents. | Australians aged 9–16 (n = 2200); unspecified ethnicity. | Data from National Children's Nutrition and Physical Activity Survey; Analysis of 24-hour time use recalls (n = 8800). | Found boys spent more time in PA, girls spent more time socializing and studying; Suggest gender differences reinforce stereotypes. |
Flintoff A, Scraton S.2001; UK | To explore young women’s perceptions of and attitudes toward PA and PE. | Girls age 15 (n = 21) from 4 schools in multi-ethnic community. | Draws on data from a study of young people's lifestyles using feminist theory. Group and individual interviews. | Found girls identified positively with PA, but disliked how PA structured. Noted support from peers/ teachers important and need for review of PE delivery. |
Guendouzi J 2004; USA | To examine extracts from women's conversations, exploring social pressure to conform to acceptable body size. | Women teachers and teenage girls. | Discourse analysis and discursive psychology. Audio taped conversation by teachers during breaks, and teenage girls at weekly gatherings. | Noted women have complex relationship with their bodies, and both help create and reproduce thin ideals. |
Heywood 2003; USA | Book chapter about author’s own female teen experiences with PA. | N/A: Book chapter | N/A: Book chapter | Notes attaining ideals is impossible, and how knowing and understanding this is important. States need for societal redefinition of gender roles. |
Holman MJ, Johnson J, Lucier M-K 2013; Canada | To explore link between body-based harassment and girls' adoption of healthy choices (eating habits and PA). | Girls and boys ages 12–14 (n = 92); Primarily white. | Discourse analysis; Focus groups presenting scenarios representing body-based harassment. | Found body-based harassment contributes to body image and relates to PA and nutrition. Noted boys took scenarios less seriously than girls: trivializing. |
Klomsten AT, Marsh HW, Skaalvik EM 2005; Norway | To examine boys' and girls' perceptions of feminine/ masculine characteristics within sport and PE. | High school students (n = 357), unspecified ethnicity. | School-based questionnaires/scales (appearance, masculine and feminine traits). | Found boys and girls appear stereotyped in sport, in regard to masculine and feminine values. |
Larkin J, Rice C 2005; Canada | To determine the extent to which curricula reflect body image concerns and make recommendations accordingly. | Girls in 7th-8th (n = 45) from 4 schools; diverse population. | Discourse analysis of Ontario health curricula; Workshops; Interviews. | Noted limitations of curricula: sending contradictory messages, not addressing school environment. Found body-based harassment played major role in constructing girls' bodies as problematic. |
Lopez V, Corona R, Halfond R 2013; USA | To examine relationship between media influences, disordered eating, appearance concerns, and gender role orientation. | Adolescents (n = 96) with mean age 15.4, 58% female, in Latino community. | Survey (demographics, BMI, hating habits, appearance, culture, media, gender roles). | Found disordered eating associated with BMI, sociocultural values, and body ideals; Media influences associated with gender role orientation. |
Mooney E, Farley H, Strugnell C 2009; Ireland | To investigate body image satisfaction and dieting in adolescent females. | Female adolescents age 15–16 (n = 124); unspecified ethnicity. | Qualitative semi-structured focus groups. | Found participants vulnerable to cultural demands, pressures of thinness, an body dissatisfaction. |
Pesa JA, Syre TR, Jones E 2000; USA | To determine whether overweight female adolescents differ from normal weight peers in psychosocial factors while adjusting for body image. | Female adolescents in 7th-12th grades (n = 3197). | Part of National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health. Scale (depression, self-esteem, connectedness, etc.); Self-reported BMI. | Found, after controlling for body image, depression not a facet in differentiating overweight adolescent girls from peers. Noted relationship between low self-esteem and being overweight. |
Richman EL, Shaffer DR 2000; USA | To explore relationship between female adolescents' precollege sport participation and college self-esteem. | Undergraduate students, (n = 220), mean age 19; 85% White. | Questionnaire (sport participation, social acceptance, academics, physical competence, body image, gender role, self-esteem). | Found early sport participation has positive impact on self esteem and body image, Noted sports promote self worth and foster flexible attitudes toward gender identity. |
Robbins LB, Pender NJ, Kazanis AS 2003; USA | To identify barriers to PA reported by middle school girls. | Girls (n = 77) ages 11–14; diverse population. | Questionnaire based on trans-theoretical model (PA barriers). | Noted barriers with highest scores: Self-conscious, not motivated, lacking peers to take part with, too busy, bad day/tired, weather, etc. |
Slater A, Tiggemann M 2010; Australia | To explore girls' reasons for ceasing participation in PA. | 49 Girls in 8th-9th grades (n = 49), primarily White. | Focus groups. | Found that PA not being 'cool' or feminine was perceived as a major barrier for girls’ participation. |
Vu MB, Murrie D, Gonzalez V, Jobe JB 2006; USA | To explore similarities and differences in girls' and boys' perceptions of girls' PA. | Girls (n = 180) and boys (n = 77) from 7th-8th grades, diverse population. | Part of TAAG intervention study; Focus groups separately with girls and boys, semi-structured interviews with girls only. | Found social influences important, and supportive environments required to support girls in PA. |
Wetton AR, Radley R, Jones AR, Pearce MS 2013; UK | To understand reasons for girls not participating in extracurricular PA by exploring barriers. | Girls from 2 high schools (n = 60), ages 15–16, unspecified ethnicity. | Explorative mixed methodology. Questionnaire (availability of PA/ barriers); Individual semi-structured interviews. | Noted girls perceived lack of ability to engage in PA; 70% felt girls teams weren't treated equally by teachers. Participants perceived stereotypes in gender roles. |
Whitehead S, Biddle S 2008; UK | To comprehensively explore adolescents girls and PA. | Girls ages 14–16 (n = 46); predominately white | Focus groups. | Found notions of femininity and achieving feminine ideals important; Suggested activity should be fun, informal, unstructured. |
Witmer L, Bocarro JN, Henderson K 2011; USA | To explore adolescent girls' attitudes toward PA, eating, and health. | Girls (n = 28) in 6th-8th grades; diverse population. | Grounded theory approach; focus groups. | Found behavior and environment interrelated, adolescents strongly influenced by social norms and peers; Noted perceptions of gender appropriate behavior and fewer opportunities for girls. |