From: Generational differences in the physical activity of UK South Asians: a systematic review
Author and year | Study design | South Asian Ethnic groups (N) | Comparator (N) | Sex | Age-group | Location | Physical activity measurement instrument |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
[7] Duncan et al. 2006 | Cross sectional | Asian (67) | White (176), Black (33) | Male and Female | 11 to 14 | Birmingham | Self-report, validated questionnaire - Four by one day |
[8] Duncan et al. 2008 | Cross sectional | South Asian (209) | White (397) | Male and Female | 11 to 14 | Birmingham | Self-report, validated questionnaire - Four by one day |
[9] Duncan et al. 2012 | Cross sectional | South Asian (67) | White (469) | Male and Female | 8 to 11 | Coventry | Pedometers worn over 4Â days |
[10] Eyre et al. 2013 | Cross sectional | South Asian (65) | White European (96) | Male and Female | 8 to 9 | Coventry | Physical activity and heart rate worn monitor for 7Â days |
[11] Falconer et al. 2014 | Cross sectional | South Asian (607) | White (1,904), Black/Black British (226) | Male and Female | 4 to 5 and 10 to 11 | 5 PCTs in England | Self-report questionnaires |
[12] Ghouri et al. 2013 | Cross sectional | South Asian (87) | European (99) | Male | 40 to 70 | Scotland | Accelerometers worn for 7Â days |
[13] Griffiths et al. 2013 | Prospective cohort | Indian (139), Pakistani (177), Bangladeshi (70) | White (5,710), Mixed (168), Black (142), Other (90) | Male and Female | Age 7 | UK | Accelerometer worn for 7Â days, during waking hours. |
[14] Harding et al. 2008 | Cross sectional | Indian (218) Pakistani/Bangladeshi (222) | White UK (589), White Other (218), Black Caribbean (453), Black African (593), Mixed (279) | Male and Female | 11 to 13 | London | Self-report physical activity questions on vigorous sports |
[15] Hayes et al. 2002 | Cross sectional | Indian (249), Pakistani (287), Bangladeshi (117) | European (749) | Male and Female | 25 to 74 | Newcastle | Self-report physical activity questionnaire, then created an index |
[16] Hemmings et al. 2011 | Cross sectional pilot | South Asian (12) | British White (11) | Male | 14 to 15 | London | Accelerometer worn for 7Â days |
[34] Hine et al. 1995 | Cross sectional | Indian (52), Pakistani (79), Bangladeshi (21) | None | Female | 18 to 74 | Bristol | Self-report questionnaire |
[17] Karlsen et al. 2010 | Cross sectional | Muslim Indian (270), Pakistani (2,120), Bangladeshi (1,943), Sikh (657), Hindu (1,195) | Christian by White British (10,577), Irish (1,729), Caribbean and No religion by White British (2,371), Caribbean (309) | Male and Female | Above 2 | England | Self-report question on taking no regular physical activity |
[18] Khunti et al. 2007 | Cross sectional | South Asian (2,732) | White European (447) | Male and Female | 11 to 16 | Leicester | Self-report questionnaire derived from Four by one day |
[19] Knight et al. 1993 | Cross sectional | Asian (128) | Non-Asian (160) | Male | 20 to 65 | Bradford | Self-report lifestyle questionnaire including exercise |
[20] Lean et al. 2001 | Cross sectional | South Asian (119) | Italian (90), General Population (50) | Female | 20 to 42 | Glasgow | Self-report question on sport and recreational exercise |
[21] McMinn et al. 2011 | Cross sectional | South Asian (487) | White European (508), Black African-Caribbean (576) | Male and Female | 9 to 10 | London, Birmingham, Leicester | Accelerometer worn for 7Â days, during waking hours. |
[22] De Munter et al. 2012 | Cross sectional | Indian (1,264) | English European (14,723), English African (1,112) | Male and Female | 35 to 64 | England | Self-report questionnaire based on Allied Dunbar National Fitness Survey |
[23] Owen et al. 2009 | Cross sectional | South Asian (494) | White European (562), Black African-Caribbean (607) | Male and Female | 9 to 10 | London, Birmingham, Leicester | Accelerometer worn for 7Â days, during waking hours. |
[24] Pollard et al. 2008 | Cross sectional | British Pakistani (60) | European (25) | Female | 20 to 40 | North East England | Self-report, validated questionnaire -International Physical Activity Questionnaire |
[25] Pollard et al. 2012 | Cross sectional | British Pakistani (67) | White British (70) | Female | 9 to 11 | North East England | Accelerometer worn for 2 school days |
[26]Pomerleau et al. 1999 | Cross sectional | South Asian (291) | European (559), Afro-Caribbean (303) | Female | 40 to 69 | London | Self-report questionnaire |
[27] Riste et al. 2001 | Cross sectional | Pakistani (132) | European (471), African-Caribbean (316) | Male and Female | 35 to 79 | Manchester | Self-report validated questionnaire |
[28] Smith et al. 2012 | Cross sectional | Indian, Pakistani, Bangladeshi | White | Male and Female | 16 to 55 | England | Self-report questionnaire based on Allied Dunbar National Fitness Survey |
[29] Williams et al. 1994 | Cross sectional | South Asian (173) | General population (344) | Male and Female | 30 to 40 | Glasgow | Self-report questionnaire. |
[30] Williams et al. 1998 | Cross sectional | British Asian (334) | Other origin (490) | Male and Female | 14 to 15 in South Asians Age 35 in General population | Glasgow | Self-report questionnaire. |
[35] Williams et al. 2010 | Cross sectional | South Asian Sikhs (571), Muslims (179), Hindus (315) | Whites (818) | Male and Female | 35 to 75 | London | Self-report, validated questionnaire -International Physical Activity Questionnaire |
[32] Williams et al. 2011 - JECH | Cross sectional | South Asian (5,421) | Whites (8,974) | Male and Female | Over 16 | England | Self-report questionnaire based on Allied Dunbar National Fitness Survey |
[31] Williams et al. 2011 - Heart | Cross sectional | Indian (1,244), Pakistani/Bangladeshi (876) | White (13,293) | Male and Female | Over 16 | England | Self-report questionnaire based on Allied Dunbar National Fitness Survey |
[33] Yates et al. 2010 | Cross sectional | South Asian (1,164) | White European (4,310) | Male and Female | 25 to 75 in South Asians 40 to 75 in White European | Leicester | Self-report, validated questionnaire -International Physical Activity Questionnaire |