Skip to main content

Table 2 Fitbit and Jawbone studies of interdevice reliability and validity (listed by author's last name and publication year)

From: Systematic review of the validity and reliability of consumer-wearable activity trackers

 

Interdevice reliability

 

Validity

Motion sensor

Steps

Distance

Physical activity

Energy expenditure

Sleep

Steps

Distance

Physical activity

Energy expenditure

Sleep

Fitbit

Fitbit Classic (also referred to as the "original Fitbit" or "Fitbit Tracker")

Adam Noah 2013 [29]

  

Adam Noah 2013 [29]

Montgomery- Downs 2012 [38]

Adam Noah 2013 [29]

  

Adam Noah 2013 [29]; Dannecker 2013 [31]: Sasaki 2015 [39]; Stahl 2014 [41]

Montgomery- Downs 2012 [38]

Fitbit Ultra

Adam Noah 2013 [29]; Dontje 2015 [32]; Mammen 2012 [36]

  

Adam Noah 2013 [29]

Meltzer 2015 [37]

Adam Noah 2013 [29]; Gusmer 2014 [34]; Lauritzen 2013 [23]; Mammen 2012 [36]; Stackpool 2014 [40]

  

Adam Noah 2013 [29]; Gusmer 2014 [34]; Stackpool 2014 [40]

Meltzer 2015 [37]

Fitbit One

Diaz 2015 [15]; Takacs 2014 [43]

Takacs 2014

 

Diaz 2015 [15]

 

Case 2015 [30]; Diaz 2015 [15]; Ferguson 2015 [33]; Simpson 2015 [46]; Storm 2015 [42]; Takacs 2014 [43]

Takacs 2014 [43]

Ferguson 2015 [33]

Diaz 2015 [15]; Ferguson 2015 [33]; Lee 2014 [35]

Ferguson 2015 [33]

Fitbit Zip

     

Case 2015 [30]; Ferguson 2015 [33]; Tully 2014 [44]

 

Ferguson 2015 [33]; Tully 2014 [44]

Ferguson 2015 [33]; Lee 2014 [35]

 

Fitbit Flex

Diaz 2015 [15]

  

Diaz 2015 [15]

 

Case 2015 [30]; Diaz 2015 [15]

  

Bai 2015 [45]; Diaz 2015 [15]

 

Jawbone

Jawbone UP

     

Ferguson 2015 [33]; Stackpool 2014 [40]; Storm 2014 [42]

 

Ferguson 2015 [33]

Ferguson 2015 [33]; Lee 2014 [35]; Stackpool 2014 [40]

de Zambotti 2015a [47]; de Zambotti 2015b; Ferguson 2015

Jawbone UP24

     

Case 2015 [30]

   

Bai 2015 [45]

  1. We found no studies for the Fitbit Force, Surge, Charge, or Charge HR, or the Jawbone UP MOVE, UP2, UP3, or UP4