Skip to main content

Table 5 Change in the proportion of packaged snacks and beverages and in the overall quality of the concession food environment by intervention group in the Eat, Play, Live trial

From: Eat, play, live: a randomized controlled trial within a natural experiment examining the role of nutrition policy and capacity building in improving food environments in recreation and sport facilities

 

n

Mean % (SD)

Intervention effecta

Baseline

Follow-up

F

p value

Packaged beverages

 Do Not Sell

  GL + CBI

9

73.1 (9.4)

74.2 (9.5)

0.478

0.62

  GL-ONLY

11

71.8 (13.6)

73.7 (9.8)

  NO-GL

16

80.3 (9.2)

85.3 (8.4)

 Sell Sometimes

  GL + CBI

9

19.0 (10.6)

20.3 (10.7)

0.895

0.42

  GL-ONLY

11

20.6 (15.9)

18.2 (11.2)

  NO-GL

16

16.6 (8.4)

11.8 (6.9)

 Sell Most

  GL + CBI

9

7.9 (3.5)

5.5 (2.9)

1.805

0.18

  GL-ONLY

11

7.6 (6.5)

8.1 (8.8)

  NO-GL

16

3.2 (3.3)

2.9 (3.9)

Packaged snacks

 Do Not Sell

  GL + CBI

7

83.4 (18.3)

69.1 (21.6)

1.550

0.23

  GL-ONLY

11

74.9 (25.6)

78.0 (12.4)

  NO-GL

16

93.6 (7.1)

93.7 (9.3)

 Sell Sometimes

  GL + CBI

7

15.1 (17.8)

26.5 (16.9)

1.213

0.31

  GL-ONLY

11

21.0 (27.4)

17.9 (9.8)

  NO-GL

16

5.6 (6.3)

5.4 (9.2)

 Sell Most

  GL + CBI

7

1.5 (2.6)

4.4 (10.2)

0.529

0.59

  GL-ONLY

11

4.1 (6.1)

4.1 (5.5)

  NO-GL

16

0.8 (1.8)

0.9 (2.1)

rNEMS-R Scoresa

 

Mean (SD)

[% ideal]

Intervention effectb

 Fast casual score

 

Baseline

Follow-up

F

p value

  GL + CBI

11

15.5 (9.0)

17.7 (6.7)

2.675

0.08

[37.3%]

[41.5%]

  GL-ONLY

11

15.5 (8.0)

13.2 (5.3)

[37.3%]

[32.9%]

  NO-GL

16

8.4 (3.5)

7.3 (3.8)

[23.8%]

[21.6%]

Fast food score

 GL + CBI

11

14.7 (8.4)

17.5 (7.2)

10.958

< 0.001c

[40.4%]

[45.0%]

 GL-ONLY

11

14.8 (6.5)

14.1 (5.1)

[40.6%]

[39.4%]

 NO-GL

16

9.2 (4.3)

4.0 (4.4)

[31.5%]

[23.0%]

  1. GL + CBI guideline + capacity building intervention facilities, GL-ONLY guideline only facilities, NO-GL no guideline facilities, rNEMS-R Nutrition Environment Measures Survey–Restaurant reduced item audit
  2. A total of 40 concessions were audited at baseline and 38 concessions were audited at follow-up. 8 facilities did not have a concession, 1 could not be audited at baseline or follow-up and 2 concessions closed between baseline and follow-up. In addition, 1 concession no longer sold packaged beverages and 2 no longer sold packaged snacks at follow-up. A total of 756 packaged beverages and 772 packaged snacks were audited at follow-up
  3. aHigher scores (possible range for fast casual: - 4.02 to + 48.27; fast food: −10.17 to + 51.35) indicate greater availability, supports for, and lower cost of healthy options
  4. bThe intervention effect is the p value for the interaction of time by condition from repeated measures ANOVA
  5. cSignificant pairwise differences between GL + CBI and NO-GL (p < 0.001); and between GL-ONLY and NO-GL (p < 0.01)