Skip to main content

Table 1 Existing international Physical Activity Guidelines for Children and Young People

From: A collaborative approach to adopting/adapting guidelines. The Australian 24-hour movement guidelines for children (5-12 years) and young people (13-17 years): An integration of physical activity, sedentary behaviour, and sleep

Criteria USA
2018a
China
2017
Chile
2017
Netherlands
2017
New Zealand
2017
Canada
2016
France
2016
Germany
2016
Norway
2016
Mexico
2015
Spain
2015
Australia
2014
Austria
2013
Denmark
2014
Paraguay
2014
Turkey
2014
Qatar
2014
Argentina
2013
Followed GRADE process N N ? N Y Y N N ? Y Y Y N N Y N N Y
Addresses clear questions (can identify PICO elements) Y N ? N Y Y Y ? ? Y Y Y N ? Y N N Y
Has benefits and harms assessments Y N ? Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ? Y Y Y Y
Assessed using AGREE N N ? N Y Y N N ? N N Y N N N N N N
Allows for updating ? N ? Y N Y Y N ? Y Y   N ? Y N N Y
Has existing and accessible evidence tables
/summaries
Y N ? Y Y Y Y Y ? N Y Y Y ? Y N N Y
Has risk of bias assessment Y N ? Y Y Y N ? ? Y Y Y N ? Y N N Y
Were integrated (24hr) ? N ? N Y Y N N ? N N N N ? N N N N
Costs associated with implementing guideline N ? ? ? N Y N N ? ? ? N N ? ? ? ? ?
Acccompanying – how they are going to implement – disseminate the guidelines N N ? ? N Y Y N ? ? ? N Y ? ? ? ? ?
  1. Reference: Appendix 1. GRADE-ADOLOPMENT (Schünemann et al., J Clin Epidemiol. 2017)
  2. aunder development during guideline development process but made available to Australian Guideline Development Group
  3. Key: Y=yes; N=no; ?=unsure