|  | Participants | Intervention | Mental health | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Author/Year/Location | Study design | N (% girl) | Age | ID level | Type | Setting | Content | Protocol (Total session/Duration per week/Total duration) | Dimension | Measure | Standardized mean difference |
Psychological health | |||||||||||
Choi & Cheung (2016) [43]; Hong Kong | RCT | E:18 (33.3) C:12 (16.7) | 7.39±0.5 | Mild | Therapeutic exercise | School | Therapeutic recreation | 24-session/180-min/1440-min | ESC | Checklist for Pupil Evaluation | ESC: 1.03** |
Maïano et al. (2002) [44]; France | Non-RCT | E:8 (0) C:16 (0) | 13.40±0.92 13.60±0.62 | Mild | Competitive sports | Community | Basketball | 56-session/120-min/6720-min | SW SC | Self-perception Profile | SW: 0.25 SC: 0.22 |
Maïano et al. (2001) [45]; France | RCT | E:16 (0) C:16 (0) | 13.50±0.80 | Mild to moderate | Competitive sports | Community | Basketball, running | 30-session/120-min/720-min | SC | Self-perception Profile | SC: 0.28 |
Ninot & Maïano (2007) [46]; France | Non-RCT | E:32 (100) C:16 (100) | 13-17 | Mild to moderate | Competitive Sports | Community | Basketball, swimming | 91-session/120-min/10920-min | SW SC | Self-perception Profile | SW: 0.50 SC: 0.37 |
Ninot et al. (2005) [47]; France | Non-RCT | E:32 (100) C:16 (100) | 13-17 | Mild to moderate | Competitive sports | Community | Swimming | 139-session/120-min/16680-min | SW SC | Self-perception Profile | SW: 0.42 SC: 0.40 |
Ninot et al. (2000) [48]; France | Non-RCT | E:32 (100) C:16 (100) | 13-17 | Mild to moderate | Competitive sports | Community | Basketball, swimming | 35-session/120-min/4200-min | SW SC | Self-perception Profile | SW: 0.73 SC: 0.70 |
Özer et al. (2012) [49]; Turkey | RCT | E:23 (0) C:15 (0) | 14.50±1.20 14.50±0.80 | Overall | Non-competitive sports | Community | Soccer | 24-session/270-min/2160-min | SC A/D | Child Behaviour Checklist | SC-Parent-proxy:0.81* SC-Teacher-proxy: 0.20 A/D-Parent-proxy: 0.12 A/D-Teacher-proxy: 0.62 |
Perić et al. (2021) [50]; Servia | RCT | E: 12 (0) C: 13 (0) | 15.68±0.49 15.72±0.46 | Mild to moderate | Competitive sports | Community | Soccer | 32-session/120-min/1920-min | A/D | 12-item Anxiety/Depression Scale | A/D-Parent-proxy: 1.315** |
Ryuh et al. (2019) [51]; USA | Non-RCT | E:10 (0) C:10 (0) | 10.80±0.60 10.40±0.70 | Overall | Non-competitive sports | School | Soccer | 20-session/450-min/1800-min | SEW | Withdrawn Behaviour Checklist | SEW: 1.45** |
Cognitive function | |||||||||||
Chen et al. (2015) [52]; Taiwan | RCT | SOT: 46 (43.5) TTT: 45 (46.7) C: 41 (43.9) | 10.90±3.90 10.60±3.60 10.70±4.00 | Mild | Aerobic exercise, therapeutic exercise | Community | Table tennis, occupational therapy | 48-session/180-min/2880-min | EF CF | EF: WCST-64 CF: Stroop color-word test | SOT-EF: 1.16** SOT-CF: 1.97** TTT-EF: 1.33* TTT-CF: 1.90** |
Giagazoglou et al. (2013) [53]; Greece | RCT | E:10 (0) C:9 (0) | 15.30±2.10 | Mild to moderate | Therapeutic exercise | School | Hippotherapy exercise | 28-session/70-min/980-min | RT | Rise from the armchair | Auditory-CE: 1.54** Auditory-OE: 2.07** Visual: 1.33** |
Mazzoli et al. (2021) [54]; Australia | RCT | E: 15 (33.3) C: 9 (44.4) | 9.90±1.00 | Mild to moderate | Cognitive exercise | School | Classroom break | 50-session/50-min/250-min | ACC IC RT WM | IC: Flanker RT & ACC: GNGT WM: NIHTB-CB | ACC: 0.07 IC: 0.15 RT: 0.37 WM: 1.07** |
Pise et al. (2018) [55]; India | RCT | E: 35 (31.4) C: 35 (48.6) | 10-15 | Mild to moderate | Cognitive exercise | NR | Yoga | 60-session/300-min/3600-min | RT | Ruler test | RT: 3.13** |
Vogt et al. (2013) [56]; Germany | Non-RCT | E:11 C:11 (46) | 16.00±1.34 | Overall | Aerobic exercise | School | Cycling | NR | RT | Cognitive performance | Visual-L: 0.33 Visual-P: 1.38** |
Yildirim et al. (2010) [57]; Turkey | RCT | E:25 (24) C:25 (20) | 14.52±1.50 14.80±1.29 | Mild | Cognitive exercise | NR | Physical fitness | 36-session/120-min/2160-min | RT | Newest Reaction Time Scale | Auditory: 0.95** Visual: 0v86** |